I don't know why people are saying Alberto Gonzales perjured himself yesterday at the Senate Judiciary Committee hearings. It was obvious to me that he was carefully choosing his words so as not to technically lie.
Here's the official transcript of the interaction between Senator Schumer and Attorney General Gonzales:
SCHUMER: And if it was about the TSP, you're dissembling to this committee. Now was it about the TSP or not, the discussion on the eighth?
GONZALES: The disagreement on the 10th was about other intelligence activities.
SCHUMER: Not about the TSP, yes or no?
GONZALES: The disagreement and the reason we had to go to the hospital had to do with other intelligence activities.
SCHUMER: Not the TSP?
Come on. If you say it's about "other," that implies not. Now say it or not.
(LAUGHTER)
GONZALES: It was not. It was about other intelligence activities.
SCHUMER: Was it about the TSP? Yes or no, please?
That's vital to whether you're telling the truth to this committee.
GONZALES: It was about other intelligence activities.
See, the TSP has changed since then, and so it was technically an other intelligence activity they were discussing at that meeting in the hospital -- an activity we might call Old TSP.
Not TSP, but Old TSP. See? Not perjury. See?
It's just like Bill Clinton saying, "I did not have sexual relations with that woman, Monica Lewinsky." Because in that circumstance he was defining "sexual relations" very narrowly. And that was perfectly fine.
Oh, wait! We impeached him for that, didn't we?
So . . . it may not be perjury, but it's definitely something worth impeaching the SOB over. Or at least it was when the Republicans were in charge. Everything is so different when the shoe is on the other foot.
