Tyler's Turn Blog

[John Tyler Connoley, Thursday July 13, 2006 at 2:18pm]
Calling All Patriots

Silver City is still buzzing about the July 4th parade entry from the Grant County Peace Coalition. The Peace Coalition marched a dozen "Guantanamo Bay Detainees" around the parade route.

Most of the buzz is from people who think it was totally inappropriate to bring up Gitmo on July 4th. The general consensus seems to be that this should have been a patriotic parade, and the Peace Coalition was being unpatriotic by dramatically visualizing the prisoner abuse scandals.

However, I say, what better day than July 4th to call our country to live up to the ideals on which it was founded? If we can't question the Bush administration's abuse of power on the anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence, then when is such questioning appropriate? Or is July 4th now just a day to salute the flag, and kiss the ring of the president?

If the freedoms written into the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution are no longer worth celebrating, then July 4th is a hollow holiday, and we might as well return our country to the English crown.

The king is dead. Long live the republic!

Update: Thanks to Stina Sieg for the photo.

Kit Austin (mail):
Amen to these sentiments. I've often wished I had stickers with the Bill of Rights on them that I could put on the windows of cars displaying the American flag, just a reminder that the flag represents rights for all citizens of this country, including the right to freely assemble and the right to hold views that differ from those of the administration or the majority.
7.13.2006 3:19pm
Ward A. Rudick (mail):
Tyler &Friends, I was out of town for the 4th of July parade but my kudos and appreciation for those who marched. Thanks for shaking things up and making people think.
WARD
7.15.2006 2:23pm
Treehugger (mail):
You asked, "What better day than July 4?" There IS no better day! I was in the small contingent that marched between the orange-suited folks and the mule-drawn "coffin." And I was psyched! Almost always we are preaching to the choir. Occasionally we do a street-corner demonstration in which we are preaching to random passersby (or rather driversby). But this time, our message was delivered right in the belly of the beast--to the people who turn out en masse to flap flags and celebrate how "wonderful" America is. The people who get their news from Fox and local newspapers. The people who don't have a clue. I'm sure it made no difference, as usual. But I did enjoy forcing a tiny bit of truth down their throats.
7.15.2006 3:48pm
Rod Rees:
I was "Uncle Sam" carrying the Abu Ghraib mock-up so I'm biased, but in my opinion this was strongest presence the peace &justice community has had in the three years I've been involved. The time has passed for "being nice" and hoping things will change, so we decided to tell the truth as clearly and dramatically as we could.

The method you choose for enacting change depends on [a] the stakes and [b] the time constraints. If you don't think we're heading toward fascism, or that we've got plenty of time to stop it, then not offending anyone might be a good strategy. But if you think we're in the midst of a national crisis that threatens the well-being of the entire world, then the raw, unvarnished truth needs to be presented at the gut-level to try to shake people out of their state of denial.

18,000 people saw our message, and every one of them had to come face-to-face, right in that moment, with where they stand on our government's policies. They might not have liked it, but at least they had to suffer a brief moment of thought.
7.15.2006 11:18pm